Upon the former defender assumed control as the club's boss in the winter, he faced scant opportunity to settle in. A congested match calendar translated to a gradual introduction to his team was impossible.
Spanish media pointed out the difficulties he would encounter, particularly managing a locker room packed with some of football's most prominent stars.
Yet forging strong relationships with the squad members appeared not to worry the former Anfield full-back.
"That is not something that worries me greatly," Arbeloa remarked at his first press briefing.
Eight weeks since, he claims those relationships are strengthening and the results on the field are coming as a result.
Building Relationships
In March, Arbeloa led his side to triumphs against teams managed by elite managers: Jose Mourinho's the Lisbon side, Pep Guardiola's Manchester City and Diego Simeone's Atletico Madrid.
Los Merengues are still four points behind the Spanish league leaders their arch-rivals, with a potentially title-deciding El Clasico in May, while their European journey proceeds with a last-eight tie against the German giants.
The team's form are on the up and the dynamic between the manager and players are growing.
"I am becoming to know the players more and more," commented the head coach after Real Madrid's 3-2 success against rivals Atletico Madrid recently.
"I came in at a juncture when I virtually had insufficient time to observe the players, to grasp where they felt comfortable, and to see how they gelled with each other."
He acknowledged the circumstances of his appointment presented unique obstacles.
"For me, it's not easy to arrive mid-season and observe how the team operates, and that's what has transformed over these two months," he added.
"Now I know my charges personally and professionally, where I can extract the optimal performance from them, and where I can implement changes."
Acclaim for Vinicius Jr
A key individual thriving under the new manager is the Brazilian winger.
He has started 16 of his new coach's 17 fixtures in charge, with his scoring rate also rising markedly - he has netted 11 times under the current boss, versus scoring just six in 27 appearances under his predecessor.
Arbeloa has prioritized restoring the forward's confidence, pushing him to express himself and show his flair rather than constraining him in terms of tactics.
"I'm lucky to have Vinicius, he's adored by the supporters. We want to see the Vinicius who has fun on the pitch, who laughs, who celebrates… that is the player I want to see," Arbeloa said in his first news conference in charge.
This method contrasts with rumors of friction under the previous manager, with the forward muttering "I'm going to quit this team" after being substituted in October's Clasico.
Arbeloa has publicly supported him, making clear he is fully backed by the coaching staff and the entire squad.
"He's one of the most threatening footballers, if not the deadliest, in the world today and he embodies what a this club's player is," added the manager.
Vinicius placed talks about his long-term prospects to one side last off-season but, last week, he stated his desire to stay clear.
"I'm only concentrating on Real Madrid and remaining there for a very long time," he told the press before Brazil's friendly match with France.
Fede Valverde Regains His Best Form Again
The Uruguayan midfielder's level has also skyrocketed since the new coach arrived.
Under the previous coach, he managed three goals and seven goal contributions from 31 appearances.
Since the manager's appointment, he has started each of the 17 of his matches in charge, netting seven times and contributing five assists.
A key factor has been a change in role back into the center of the park.
During Alonso's tenure, the player at times struggled to cement a starting spot in his natural role, being used in unusual positions such as full-back.
While the move was in part because of fitness issues to other players, Valverde's displeasure was evident. "I wasn't made to be a right-back," he stated.
Yet now, back in his natural habitat, the midfielder is prospering.
He has bagged six strikes in just a month, including a three-goal haul against City and a crucial goal in a 3–2 triumph over their city rivals.
Youth Integration, Greater Possibilities?
Arbeloa's background as manager of Real Madrid's B team has made integrating young players into the senior side feel natural, so it was expected to anticipate him to give promising youngsters opportunities.
This occurred particularly when Real Madrid played their opponents recently and the coach handed playing time to six youth team players.
One player, in particular, has rapidly established himself as one of Arbeloa's most talented disciples.
At just 18 years and 226 days old, he became the most youthful player in the club's history to start twice in the European Cup knockout stages, surpassing Vinicius' milestone by 10 days.
Asked what it signified to see five academy graduates on the pitch, Arbeloa couldn't contain his joy.
"I believe I can be content after a night like tonight," he said.
"I was just speaking with some of them, who were the first players I managed when they were 13 or 14, and to be able to give them the chance to play at the Bernabeu is a lifelong dream realized for me."
While Arbeloa might be well-acquainted with the Castilla players, he admits fitness setbacks have limited his exposure